Written by Lubaina Kapasi. Graphic by Abra Manfred.
Imagine meeting everyone you know, your mother, your professor, your closest friend, a stranger, someone you desperately want to impress, someone you cannot stand, for the first time, all on the same day.
Would they all meet the same person?
Probably not.
You would speak differently, laugh differently, maybe even sit differently. You would be louder in one room and quieter in another. Most of these adjustments would happen without you noticing.
By the end of the day, you’d have introduced several versions of yourself.
And every single one would have been you.
Halloween makes masks seem simple. You put one on, become someone else for a night, and take it off when you get home. The masks we wear every day aren’t nearly as easy to remove.
We learn to wear them early. A child gets praised for their maturity and learns not to ask for help. Another makes everyone laugh and becomes the funny one, even on days when nothing feels funny.
Nobody hands us a costume. We put one together from other people’s reactions–alaugh, a compliment, a disappointed look.
Eventually, it fits.
We accuse people of being fake when they act differently around different people. Yet we all do the same thing. We call it respect at home, professionalism at work, confidence in public.
Maybe changing how we behave doesn’t automatically make us dishonest. Maybe a mask can be a way of understanding the room.
We’re so busy wondering whether people accept us for who we are that we rarely ask whether we let other people be themselves around us.
Think about the friend who never disagrees with you, the sibling who always says they’re fine, and the person who laughs at your jokes even when they’re not funny.
Maybe that’s just who they are. Maybe that’s who they’ve learned to be around you.
Maybe someone edits their stories before telling you because you’ve laughed at them before. Maybe a friend hides good news because they know you’ll turn it into a comparison. Maybe someone has stopped correcting you because disagreeing never seems worth the trouble.
You might think you know these people better than anyone, but what if you’ve only met the versions of them that feel safe around you?
And then there’s the strange way we’ve turned authenticity into another performance.
We praise people for being unapologetically themselves, not following trends, and saying exactly what they think. But sometimes even that becomes a role we feel pressured to play.
We dress differently to prove we’re original. We announce that we don’t care what people think, then wait to see who agrees.
If you’re trying to convince everyone you’re not performing, isn’t that a performance too?
Perhaps there isn’t one perfect, untouched version of ourselves waiting underneath every mask. Perhaps being a person means changing, choosing, and sometimes contradicting ourselves.
The danger begins when the choice disappears, like when the funny one can’t admit they’re sad and the strong one can’t ask for help when being “real” becomes just another thing to get right.
So here’s an experiment.
For one day, notice the version of yourself that appears when someone important enters a room. Notice which opinions you soften, which stories you exaggerate, which silences you rush to fill. Don’t correct anything. Don’t try to become more authentic. Just watch.
Then ask yourself something uncomfortable:
If nobody had ever rewarded you for being this person, would you still have become them?
And if you cannot answer, perhaps that is the most honest face you have worn all day.