Book to Movie Adaptations: Do the visuals and widespread impact make up for what gets cut?

Written by Bri LaMere. Graphic by Avery Melhado.

The first long chapter book I read that was turned into a movie was “Harry Potter and the Sorcerer’s Stone,” by JK Rowling, the first novel in its series. When I found the DVDs of all eight movies in my basement, I couldn’t wait to keep reading. After mild disappointment that some friendships and spells didn’t translate to the movie, my parents explained that if every scene in the book were acted out, it would be days long. Well, I still wished there was that version. 

Camryn George, an acting major at SCAD, offered the insight that movie adaptations give people who can’t or struggle with reading comprehension an option to experience a story. 

It’s more fun in general to put a face to characters from favorite books and see the creatures in fiction as if they were real, like the three-headed dog in the first Harry Potter movie. Regardless of having read the book and knowing Voldemort was a character, I had nightmares about his likeness in the first movie for months. It’s a double edged sword to have a film version as a kid who has no idea what horrific features that makeup on a bald man can create. 

The one year anniversary of HBO’s adaptation of “Heated Rivalry” passed, and those who have read and watched them both draw many differences between the two. “Heated Rivalry” was originally written by an author with the pen name Rachel Reid, published in 2019. It’s the second book in the “Game Changers” series, which amplifies her portrait of gay men’s experiences and everyday life as a professional hockey player. In 2025 the screen adaptation was directed by Jacob Tierney, an openly gay man from Canada. 

Copies of “Heated Rivalry” were well stocked in high school libraries and most tween girls had gotten their hands on a copy at some point in 2019. There wasn’t a void of that audience with the show either. But people’s reactions exploded when the series came out, and meaningful,new takeaways were amplified. Men who had played hockey as young adults reported how validated they felt by this story, oftentimes being the only queer man in the locker room. A gay man’s adaptation of the story made it more relatable and convinced a fraction of new watchers to go back and read the book version. 

The newest adaptation of Stephen King’s “Carrie” was released on Prime Video at the beginning of October, 2026, and critics have vastly differing opinions. Andrew Dotson , a senior Film and Television major, has directed multiple homemade and class-assigned horror films with similar elements to this series.  

“There’s a lot of liberties they take in the new Carrie, but they add in a lot of stuff from the books that aren’t in any of the movies,” says Dotson. 

While the recent release is the fourth remake since the original in 1976, this is the first TV series instead of a film. The ability to treat each episode like a chapter is more available to build in pauses for. It’s usually impossible to get the full picture of the story through the movie because of everything that’s skipped over, but the personification of a character and watching them act out the words that were read makes it worth it. 

Popular culture is made more vibrant by the film and television industry. It’s easier to access and faster to picture details. Books and their movie adaptations hold their own purpose for the consumer to take away. A ripple effect occurs for both media forms in favor of the other that gets people talking.

TOP