Written by Jax Warner. Photo by Jax Warner.
“To be, or not to be: that is the question.” Hamlet 3.1
In William Shakespeare’s “Hamlet,” death is never far from the surface. It haunts the characters, shapes their decisions, and forces them to confront what it means to be alive. In “Elsinore,” those questions become painfully real. On day five of the SCAD Savannah Film Festival, director Simon Stone brought audiences the story of Ian Charleson (Andrew Scott), a Scottish actor whose final months were defined by his determination to play one of Shakespeare’s most demanding roles while living with AIDS. It is an unbelievably heartbreaking story, but one that finds just as much room for joy, hope, and an unwavering passion for the arts.
Set in 1989, “Elsinore” follows Charleson as he gets the opportunity to return to a role he first played roughly 15 years earlier. When actor Daniel Day-Lewis abruptly leaves Richard Eyer’s production of “Hamlet” at London’s National Theater, Charleson is offered the chance to take his place. By then, Charleson had been living with HIV for several years, and his illness had progressed into AIDS. Despite his declining health and his doctor’s (Olivia Colman) concerns about the physical demands of the role, he is determined to take the stage.
“Elsinore” weaves together the tragedy of Shakespeare’s play and the tragedy unfolding in Charleson’s own life. Hamlet is surrounded by loss, struggling to make sense of death and searching for meaning in a world that seems determined to take everything from him. Charleson faces those same questions, but from the other side of the stage. As he rehearses and performs “Hamlet” during the final months of his life, the words he speaks become increasingly difficult to separate from his own reality.
Charleson died on Jan. 6, 1990, just seven weeks after his final performance. Knowing that timeline makes the film especially difficult to watch. Every rehearsal carries the weight of what is happening outside the theater, and every performance becomes a reminder of how much Charleson wanted to accomplish before he ran out of time. Yet what stayed with me most was not simply the sadness of that parallel, but the determination behind it. Charleson wants to play Hamlet because he loves the work, because he still has something to give, and because his illness does not take away his passion for acting.
Andrew Scott brings that contradiction to life in a performance that makes Charleson feel like a person rather than simply a tragic figure. There is grief here, but there is also humor, ambition, and a deep love for theater. Those moments of joy matter. They remind us that Charleson’s life cannot be reduced to his diagnosis or the circumstances of his death. He was an actor and artist whose commitment to his craft remained unwavering, even when his body could no longer keep up with his ambitions.
The film occasionally leans heavily into its emotional moments, but I found it difficult not to be swept up in the story it tells. The parallels between Charleson and Hamlet give the film a weight that lingers, particularly as the boundaries between the character’s suffering and the actor’s experience begin to blur. It is one thing to watch a tragedy unfold on stage; it is another to recognize how closely its questions resemble those asked by the person performing it.
At the SCAD Savannah Film Festival, actress Billie Piper and casting director Jessica Roane came to discuss the film with audiences. Their appearance was a fitting addition to a story about the people who dedicate themselves to bringing other lives to the screen and stage. “Elsinore” is a reminder of how much of ourselves we bring to the stories we tell, whether we are the ones performing them or the ones watching from the audience.
What I love most about “Elsinore” is that it never feels as though heartbreak is the only thing worth taking away from Charleson’s story. It is just as much about the joy of doing what you love, the people who make difficult moments bearable, and the things we leave behind through our work. Shakespeare’s “Hamlet” is a tragedy, but Charleson’s relationship with the play becomes something else entirely: a testament to the power of art to give us purpose when the suture feels uncertain.
I left “Elsinore” with a broken heart, but also with a renewed appreciation for the arts and the people who give so much of themselves to them. It reminded me why I love stories in the first place. They allow us to sit with grief, find beauty in difficult places, and recognize pieces of ourselves in lives that might otherwise feel far removed from our own.